[If he was in the room with her, he'd put his hands up placatingly.] Even if I was told nothing, it's pretty clear this is an ongoing thing.

I checked in with her, too. I like you both. There weren't details shared. [Well. She didn't go into detail or specifics about what happened. But now he knows how Ellie lost her fingers.] I know just enough to know that there are good reasons you two don't see eye to eye.

Pretty sure she gets that she's in the wrong, when these conversations turn the way they do. Maybe it's not a lost cause yet.